Saturday, October 16, 2010

Nine Nobel Lit Snubs

So I read this article the other day listing the top nine "snubs" in the Nobel Prize for Literature. I (because I'm just so smart and will have no real repercussions for doing so) am going to take this idea one step further: If nine were snubbed, nine were given undeserved awards. Who, pray tell, are the ridiculous nine?

Snub #1: Vladimir Nabokov (1899-1977)
  • Undeserving #1: Michail Aleksandrovich Sholokhov (1965 recipient)
  • If the Swedish Academy (the body that awards the Nobel Prize in Literature) had wanted to award the prize to a Russian, Nabokov should have been the choice. Possibly, his label as a Russian-American prevented him from this top award? But who's pointing fingers. . .

Snub #2: Philip Roth (1933- )
  • Undeserving #2: Elfriede Jelinek (2004 recipient)
  • Outside of Austria and German-speaking readers, does anyone know her? Since 2004 and the awarding of the Nobel Prize in Literature, has the world rushed to read her novels and plays? Does the Academy sometimes award authors because they are both Communist and feminist? Should I stop before I write something I may later regret?

Snub #3: Marcel Proust (1871-1922)
  • Undeserving #3: Knut Pedersen Hamsun (1920 recipient)
  • This award, presented for a single work of literature (to a Norwegian author, oddly enough), Growth of the Soil, is not really what the Nobel Prize has come to stand for. Too, Hamsun came in later years to support Nazi Germany, quite a moral failing in the scheme of things.

Snub #4: James Joyce (1882-1941)
  • Undeserving #4: Henri Bergson (1927 recipient)
  • Bergson, awarded the prize "in recognition of his rich and vitalizing ideas and the brilliant skill with which they have been presented," was chiefly a philosopher, not a writer. Given an author like James Joyce whose brilliant skill pioneered a movement (Modernism), catalyzed--and continues to catalyze--writers the world over, and shows up on tattoos ("yes I said yes I will yes"--from the last line of Ulysses--on the shoulder of a former classmate of mine), the award in 1927 no doubt should have been his.

Snub #5: Anton Chekhov (1860-1904)

Snub #6: Jorge Luis Borges (1899-1986)
  • Undeserving #6: Eugenio Montale (1975 recipient)
  • If the year 1975 necessitated an award for "distinctive poetry," Borges not Montale should have been recognized.

Snub #7: Leo Tolstoy (1828-1910)
  • Undeserving #7: Rudolf Christoph Eucken (1908 recipient)
  • The Academy presented Eucken this award "in recognition of his earnest search for truth, his penetrating power of thought, his wide range of vision, and the warmth and strength in presentation with which in his numerous works he has vindicated and developed an idealistic philosophy of life"--all qualities of Tolstoy, an author whom we still actually read.

Snub #8: Ezra Pound (1885-1972)
  • Undeserving #8: None
  • In both 1914 and 1918, no award was presented in the area of Literature, with funds "allocated to the Special Fund of this prize section." An obvious snub, as both years fall within the heyday of the Imagist movement, Pound's stamp on the literary world.

Snub #9: Mark Twain (1835-1910)
  • Undeserving #9: Selma Lagerlöf (1909 recipient)
  • Apparently Lagerlöf, a future member of the Swedish Academy most known for her work in children's literature, was selected in a year of internal turmoil within the Swedish Academy. Hmm. . .

No comments:

Post a Comment